A- A A+

Justice system 'failing' young indigenous Australians

Kathryn Kernohan |  05 June 2018

Jesuit Social Services is calling on the federal government to raise the age of criminal responsibility to 14 to better address the needs of vulnerable children.

A new report says Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander young people are just five percent of the population but on an average day in 2016-17, represent half those under supervision. 

The Australian Institute of Health and Welfare’s Youth Justice in Australia 2016-17 report, published days before National Reconciliation Week last week, shows that while only about five per cent of young people aged 10-17 in Australia are Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders (ATSI), 50 per cent of young people aged 10-17 under supervision on an average day in 2016-17 were Indigenous.

“Over the last decade, Closing the Gap reports have shown that a disproportionate number of ATSI people face significant disadvantage in many aspects of life including health, education and employment,” says Jesuit Social Services chief Julie Edwards.

“The AIHW report shows many young Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people face challenges early in life that can lead to a lifetime of cycling in and out of the justice system. We need to intervene early to address the factors behind anti-social behaviour and break the cycle of offending”.

Ms Edwards says that the data also shows that the over-representation of young Indigenous people in the justice system is increasing.

“Five years ago, Indigenous children aged 10-17 were 15 times more likely than non-Indigenous children to have involvement with the justice system but now they are 18 times more likely.

Jesuit Social Services has recommended a range of solutions to prevent young ATSI people from having contact with the youth justice system, including raising the age of criminal responsibility from 10 (the current age) to 14.

“No primary school aged child should be in prison. We should be taking a restorative approach with children aged under 14 to give them every opportunity to lead healthy lives,” Ms Edwards said.

“We also need a greater range of culturally-specific programs that work with young ATSI people and help connect them to culture, education and family. ”



Similar articles

Reconciliation the new safe word

Daniel James | 06 June 2018

National Reconciliation Week has just finished. It’s a week that is becoming more and more dubious in the eyes of many. The week is bookended by two nationally significant dates, 27 May the date of the successful 1967 Referendum and June 3 when we celebrate the historic High Court decision that overturned the lie that is Terra Nullius, known as the Mabo decision.


The cases of murdered Aboriginal people need to be heard

Amy McQuire | 06 June 2018

In 1988, Aboriginal teenager Mark Haines was found on the train tracks in Tamworth, northern NSW. Immediately, the police thought it was a suicide. That was despite the family knowing that it was “out of character”, and despite the testimony of the train driver who found him, a railway investigator who saw that there was little blood, and a towel folded neatly under his head.

Abused indigenous children need safe homes not derailed debate

Helen Davidson | 10 May 2018

Revived arguments about the removal of Indigenous children from their families are just the latest instalment of a “narrow debate” bringing Australia closer to another Northern Territory-style intervention, writes Helen Davidson for The Guardian.

Why I didn’t sit with the other Maori girls at school

Liana MacDonald | 01 April 2018

Stories about racial injustice in state institutions are no great surprise if you’re Māori, because you have stories of your own — although maybe you don’t think these stories are of any value. In a society that doesn’t like talking about race and racism, this perception is unsurprising. In fact, these stories have great power because they speak of oppression and racial inequality, writes Liana MacDonald for e-Tangata

How The Gap Widened, And How To ‘Refresh’ The Policy Approach For Remote Indigenous Australia

Jon Altman | 01 April 2018

Every year a report card on the government’s performance in lifting Indigenous Australians out of poverty documents more and more failure, and a widening gap. Professor Jon Altman takes to New Matilda to explain why